A Very Martha Memorial Day, Part 1: The Savory

Martha Stewart's Macaroni and Cheese

Martha Stewart’s Macaroni and Cheese

While in reality I may not strive to be totally like her, I can say with complete honesty that I really love Martha Stewart. I think it’s awesome that she came out of prison missing fresh lemons the most. And the fact that she can make a crumb cake with Ludacris and bake brownies with Snoop Dogg just endears me further. Martha seems to be able to bounce back — better than ever — no matter what happens to her and I admire that.

I also admire her seemingly always perfect recipes. There’s a reason the woman is an internationally famous domestic goddess. I haven’t ever had a recipe of hers turn out sub-par, which is why I chose several of them for our (pre*) Memorial Day party.

*My MO for Memorial Day (and Labor Day) is to host a BBQ on the Sunday prior. This is useful in case people have already made plans for Monday and it allows me to spend that day recouping and relaxing instead of entertaining. It’s a win/win strategy that I highly suggest.

Anyways, my husband wanted to do a traditional “Americana-style” BBQ. This means he was in charge of the grill — a task he took to happily, deciding to smoke a rather hefty (13 pound) beef brisket over apple wood. Here’s a sneak peek:

Applewood Smoked Beef Brisket

Applewood Smoked Beef Brisket

Oh yeah…it was serious!

I, on the other, took control of the side dishes. My husband had mentioned wanting mac and cheese so I used this recipe of Martha’s, which has a cult-like following online with commenters referring to it as “crackaroni” since it’s impossible to quit eating. Totally accurate name by the way, I actually had to pry myself away from the pan.

It’s fairly simple — make a bechamel, par-cook the noodles (to very al dente), mix together and bake. Familiar stuff if you’ve made mac and cheese before. But it’s the little details that make it outstanding. The blend of cheeses works fantastic together, remaining creamy not gritty, and the buttered bread cubes (not crumbs) on top were a total eye opener. Seriously phenomenal.

Martha Stewart's Macaroni and Cheese

I’ve died and gone to cheese heaven!

I will ‘fess up to being totally sad that there was only a tiny portion left of it at the end of the night. But I guess that’s good for my health — this dish, sadly, is what cardiologists have nightmares about.

I also used Martha’s recipe for Creamy Coleslaw. While we live in the age of Asian-style, Brussels sprout, apple-jicama and broccoli slaws (all of which I love by the way), we wanted old-school coleslaw and I trusted Martha to steer me right.

Her recipe is classic coleslaw to a T — cabbage, carrots and onion with a dressing made primarily from sour cream, mayonnaise and apple cider vinegar. I subbed out the sour cream for non-fat Greek yogurt but kept everything else as written. It was tangy, creamy and crunchy. In fact, my husband pronounced it perfect; I concur. It was also killer in a brisket/sweet roll sandwich — I’m drooling just remembering it.

Creamy Coleslaw

Creamy Coleslaw

And speaking of the brisket, look at this beauty!

Applewood Smoked Beef Brisket

It might have been bigger than the baby!

Applewood Smoked Beef Brisket

Close up of the smokey goodness!

We started it in the oven around 2am, seasoned only with salt and pepper. Around 11 am, my husband transferred it to the smoker for another 6 hours. It was divine — smokey, fatty, delicious. And enormous — we had enough food to feed a small army!

All in all, it was a pretty wonderful day — the weather wasn’t perfect, but there were a few hours where we could all sit outside and chat as we celebrated the beginning of grilling season with tasty beer and a bottle of bubbles. I also had a very special last-minute guest but that will have to be covered, along with dessert, in the next Very Martha post.

Until then here’s some more pictures of our feast!

Grilled Japanese eggplant w. Chimichurri

Grilled Japanese eggplant with Chimichurri and Manchego Cheese (sure it’s not “Americana,” but wow — it was delicious!)

Grilled Sweet Corn

Grilled Sweet Corn

Grilled Garlic Scapes with Lemon

Grilled Garlic Scapes with Lemon

16 thoughts on “A Very Martha Memorial Day, Part 1: The Savory

  1. wow–totally knock your socks off amazing–all of it!!!! I’ve never been to a party where scapes were served. You’re one classy lady 🙂 Am not so much a Martha fan and prefer you to her very much!

    • Ha! thanks! =) Scapes are everywhere in the PNW right now and I’m loving it. So tasty. I am also starting to *finally* get sick of leftover brisket sandwiches…need a good veg detox!

    • Thanks! Everything turned out awesome — but man, that mac and cheese was the winner for sure. Leave it to Martha! I agree, she is just perfect at the party details. I don’t have the cookie cookbook but I’ve been mooning over it enough over the past few years I should just buy it.

  2. The brisket looks so delicious I would’ve been worried I’d have accidentally eaten the woman and baby in the background in my voracious blindness.

  3. I’ve never really had the mac & cheese fetish that so many do. But I believe that one might change that. I agree about Martha. Her (or her staff’s) recipes are unfailingly good. And she seems to have a sense of humor.

    • I definitely get dreamy about mac and cheese, but rarely make it because it’s just so decadent and I feel guilty. This one was SO good though I wish I had thought to hide an extra pate of it somewhere! And yeah, I have a feeling Martha’s staff is responsible for many of “her” ideas — nobody can have the time to do everything that she seems to do! — but man, they are tasty.

  4. Everything looks amazing! I can’t wait until the husband is employed again so we can throw a proper party!

Leave a comment, question or reply!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s