Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti: Happy Dunking!

Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti

Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti

In a recent post, I mentioned that I had been on a biscotti kick. I baked several different types over the holidays, all sweet, made with sugar and various types of nuts. But in the comment section, thanks to a fellow blogger, I got wind of a different type of biscotti made with cheese and pepper that sounded too intriguing to forget. I love it when things that you expect to be simply sweet are turned into something savoy instead — like the sage macaron I had for lunch today.

Cheddar for BiscottiI googled the recipe reviews for the link that she gave me (Parmesan and black pepper biscotti) and it sounded like a winner. However, I didn’t happen to have any Parmesan cheese at my house and I had just polished off the last of the pecorino, which is my go-to substitute. But I did, thanks to my stepdad who is also a cheese fanatic, have a huge hunk of two-year aged white cheddar from Wisconsin that was begging to be used in something fun.

I’m sure I could have switched out the cheddar in the original recipe just fine but I thought I’d do some additional internet digging to see what else was out there. And I stumbled upon what seemed like the perfect fit — a recipe from the famed Mark Bittman for Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti.

I ran to the kitchen so fast, I practically hurt myself!

But it was all so worth it…

Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti -- after the first baking

Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti — after the first baking

Sliced and ready for the oven again

Sliced and ready for the oven again

Toasted and delicious!

Toasted and delicious!

Now in case you’re wondering what to dunk your savory biscotti in, do as the Italians do. In Italy biscotti is usually dipped into wine rather than coffee. I didn’t have any Vin Santo hanging out at my house, but I did have a lovely bottle of dessert wine from Argyle Winery in Oregon.

A perfect pair

A perfect pair

what goes better with a cheese biscotti than more cheese?

What goes better with cheese biscotti than more cheese?

The only things I’d do different next time would be to bump up the cayenne just a bit (maybe a heaping 1/4 tsp) and to make up a batch of tomato soup because these would be fantastic dipped in a steamy bowl of tomato goodness. They reminded me a super-crunchy cheddar goldfish cracker — an adult version, with just a hint of spice.

Trust me — whether you dip them in soup, wine or just eat them on their own, these really are a treat. Just be warned the recipe only makes about 16 pieces — so you might just want to double it!

Supposedly you need to dunk five times for the best biscotti experience...

Supposedly you need to dunk five times for the best biscotti experience…

11 thoughts on “Cheddar and Cayenne Biscotti: Happy Dunking!

  1. Yeah, let’s do like the Italians do! 😉 Just kidding!
    Your biscotti look delicious and the combination of cheddar and cayenne for biscotti is very intriguing…to say the least. Very well done! 🙂

  2. I’m glad to see you’ve made these savoury biscotti, even if they are not the ones we talked about. If you’d like to know, I made the parmesan and black pepper biscotti and they were amazeballs. I only made half the batch and immediately regretted the decision as they were all inhaled by the husband and friends in 15 minutes. I’m also incredibly tempted to make these now because they look so good and I have a hunk of Tillamook white cheddar sitting in my fridge.

    • I’m making the Parm ones this week! Bought the cheese over the weekend and I’m so excited. Did you serve them with anything? I’m just making them to snack on in general, but I’m thinking of chilling some bubbly just to try them together. And if you have cheddar, you should definitely try out the cayenne ones. Then we can really do some critical biscotti research!

  3. Pingback: Parmesan Biscotti: The antidote for your candy overdose | Attempts in Domesticity

Leave a comment, question or reply!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s